Finding Pie to 3 Places: Tell Us Who Has the Best Slice for $50 Gift Card

In honor of National Pie Month, your local editors tried pie in Frankfort, New Lenox and Mokena. Tell us which spot you think reigns supreme for a shot at winning a $50 gift card to a local restaurant.

For this week's Chowdown Showdown, we skipped the meal and went right to dessert, trying pie in Frankfort, New Lenox and Mokena.

Local editors Joe Vince (Frankfort), Michael Sewall (New Lenox) and Paul Dailing (Mokena) tried a bowl at restaurants in their respective Patch towns.

Read our reviews below, learn how to post your own and 

Enrico's, Frankfort (3.5 of 5 stars)

The good: Fresh pie on a nice graham cracker crust, fluffy whipped cream. It's worth noting that the banana cream pie is the only pie that you don't need to order in advance. Enrico's offers whole pies—dark chocolate cream, coconut cream and fabulous cheesecake—with at least 48 hours notice.

The bad: The banana flavors competed with each other too much—the artificial banana flavoring in the pie filling (pudding) with real banana slices plus the dried banana chips on top were too confusing for my palate. 

Prime Time, New Lenox (4 of 5 stars)

The good: Prime Time puts a nice twist on the traditional apple pie by drizzling it with caramel—making it a caramel apple pie! The cinnamon in the apples wasn't overpowering, and the pie came a la mode.

The bad: The pie crust wasn't crispy, and that was before the ice cream made it even a bit more soggy.

Double Yolk Pancake House, Mokena (5 of 5 stars)

The good: Oh, man. The cherry pie was awesome; sweet, but with a hint of tartness. Whipped cream on top. It tastes so good, makes a grown man cry. Sweet cherry pie. (Part of this review might be Warrant lyrics.)

The bad: Nothing really bad about the pie itself, but here's a protip for ordering: Pie's not actually on the menu. You have to see what's in the case by the door when you come in and order a slice of that when you're at your table.

Judy Niemann-Vander Veen February 12, 2012 at 05:42 PM
Country Charm Restaurant in New Lenox has marvelous pies. They will warm them for you & put a scoop of ice cream on if you like. The crust is flakey. I prefer the triple berry pie. My mom likes the apple.
Michael Sewall February 12, 2012 at 06:15 PM
Thanks, Judy! We previously did a pumpkin pie chowdown showdown and I went to Country Charm that time around. It was delicious!
Mary Beth Windberg February 12, 2012 at 07:20 PM
I have to go with Country Charm too - we had three different pies from there for Thanksgiving and all were absolutely delicious. The Apple was as close to my grandma's that i have ever eaten.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »